I’ll begin to explain that I saw before this painting of Edvard Munch, I don´t remember where, maybe it was in some book, or some museum or some program of art, in tv, I am not sure...
My interpretation of it maybe is not like an expert people, for example an art critic or an other artist who can understand better the painting, however my personal opinion is that this image produced in me an anguish and despair sensations. I believe that the man is suffering a lot and the people are not interested in his problems, hence I think that he feels alone and perhaps is going to exploit.
“The scream”, by Eduard Munch, is a very interesting picture. When I saw this picture the first time I felt despaired. It made me feel afraid and anxious, it was a deep feeling that I can not explain. I think that I would call this picture real art, because it made me feel different emotions. I read something about the author of this picture that made me understand the real meaning of it. Edward Munch had a really bad life when he was just a kid; his father was very strict. Besides that, Eduard Munch saw how his mother and sister died. I think that it is something very shocking for a kid. In my mind I thought about how I would feel if I see someone dying, and I did not like it. I think that Edward Munch expressed his feelings and emotions in this picture, in that difficult moment of his life.
Well, firstly I don´t have words to describe what did I really feel when I saw the picture "The Scream", by Edward Munch.
But, the thing I really admire about the picture is the way that the artist painted, because if you examine the background you can see the man that is backwards the man who is with the scram face.
I think that the artist wanted to show the way he felt, because the face and the form that he mixtures the colors, the ones that are like colors wich you can feel a deep sense inside of you and looking to the scream, remind me that sometimes I feel like that picture and its sure sometimes nobody can help you and you are like AGHHH!but this have only one sense to me, existencial angst.
For me this image speaks of a person that his life was very quiet, a person who wanted to express it differently, the type of paint used is very strange character who seems to believe that it is expressing their feelings like the artist wanted to reflect. I I think this character was punished for what he is doing as a gesture despair. This image intrigues me the truth is not what to think, I view it is very quiet, the bad is not how to express what sorry to see this painting.
This paint was named "The Scream" and it was done bye the famous artist Eduard Munch. Well first I wanto say that it is a good work because I can feel something no exactly but that the artist in that moment was upset about a situation that he live may be he lost a partner or he was alone in that moment. Well this are the feelings that the artist would like us to feel when we see the picture on the wall in front of our faces. First of all I feel bad because he looks like if she is screaming and I have a sensation of sadness
This famous painting was made from 1893 to 1910, some authors think that this is an expressionalist painting. Actually, they also exist some few versions of this paiting. The Munch Museum holds one of two versions and the National Gallery of Norway holds the other painted version.
The scream has been the target of several high-profile art thefts. In my personal opinion, this painting seems to be very strange for me, but it looks like the author had some feelings to express and he express them the way he wanted.
"The scream" by Edvard Munch is a really good painting. I like it but, at the time, it makes me feel scared and lost. Honestly I like the technique that the author used, it seems like something soft. Also there is a man, or something like a man, in the back of the one who is screaming, and he is just looking at him. When I saw this painting before, I didn't want to see it again.
In my opinion the author wanted to say what he was feeling in that moment, the moment that he painted "The Scream". I think, maybe he had problems and with the paint he took them out of his head.
I can say this painting is real art, because it expresses feelings, but also causes feelings. The author just had an idea and he expressed it.
This paiting is titled "The Scream" by Edvard Munch, is a paiting that conveys variety of things, but each one thinks what he sees in the painting, this paiting for me is a kind sentimental expressed by the type of color and shape how are jobs. I noticed that the paiting is by a painter`s work that expresses what he thinks and is mainly in his imagination. I liked the paiting, it`s a good piece of art.
This painting by Edvard Munch for me is weird because the paint is sad, i dont know why but just view it i start thinking about the feelings that the author wants to convey in the painting whith this face of sad or scared. But realy this painting is beauty and interesting.
I think the autor tries to tell us something of his life that he did´t likes. I like this painting by the combination of colors that he use.
This painting "The scream" by edvard Munch, is a very good painting. I really admire the picture because the man (Like a ghost) is express(feelings) the fear in his or the all the fear in the world.
I think that the background in the painting is very sad, because i think that express the fear in the world, the contamination in rivers, in mountains and the pollution in the air.
I think that this painting is art because it gives something to talk about.
This picture is very shocking for me. It transmit deep emotions like fear and anxiety. It seems that the character is being trapped in a place with no way out. In my opinion the character behind the main one could be the "death" that is comming for him. The main character already knows that there is no chance to scape from his own destiny.
The paint is named the scream. But isn't that weird? I mean, a scream is a sound and we can't see sounds. or can we? If Bethoveen could play a "moonlight" on piano, why couldn't we look at a scream on a painting. Oh! but is he/she really screaming? Maybe you have felt the sensation that you see something horrible and you try to scream but no matter how much you open your mouth any sound come out from your throat.
And another question. Is it really a person? Look carefuly, it has strange face and no hair. Actually it looks more like a soul... for me. After anilizing the picture a little more it remeinded me of a character from the Greek Mythology. Caronte was a boatman who paddled around the Aquerón river looking for souls of people who have just died. If the soul had money to pay the trip, Caronte carried it to the inferno where Hades was. Nevertheless, if the soul didn't have money to pay, it would be punished by sataying through the river until Caronte agree to pick it up to hell.
And the painting shows exactly how do I imaging the expression of a soul who couldn't pay Caronte. But am I trying to define what did the author wanted to express or am I explaining what the painting causes on me? In other words: Is the soul screaming at me or is it screaming as a reaction of something?
Because, if we're looking for the author's feelings, here they are:
"I was walking along with two friends- the sun was setting- suddenly the sky turned blood red- I paused, feeling exhausted, and leaned on the fence. There was blood and tongues of fire above the blue-black fjord and the city- my friends walked on, and I stood there trembling with anxiety- and i sensed an infinite scream passing through nature"
He mentioned 2 friends and on the painting only apears one... well in fact that's not a mistery. Is because the picture in our blog was cut and it only shows us one Munch's friend. But why did they look so calm on the painting? Why did they keep walking on? Didn't they realize of what was happening? or it was all Munch imagination?
The paint “scream” by Edward Munch is amazing, when I saw it, a lot of ideas and feelings came to me, the most important feeling that I can describe is desperation to live in a different world, but, why a different world? Well I think that because the scene is very weird, the sky is red and the ground is blue but it looks like turbid water and that cause the idea that the man or woman screams of desperation but it looks that he or she is scare too.
Another important detail is that the person is looking to the left side like trying to look backward and I think that can represent the problems or the bad life that he had in the past.
This picture is a great example of expressionistic art because the artist is trying to show his feeling with different aspect of the painting, like color and shapes that cause different kind of feelings in a person.
The scream. It makes me feel weird. I don´t really know if it makes me feel kind of afraid of something, something that i can interpretated like the doomsday, according to the colors of the backgrounds. It is clearly a sunset, because the red themes. It makes me think that the "person" that is screaming is actually trying to get out of the painting or screaming forthe outside. I think so for the type of movement that is doing this character, his curved body and the position of his hands are some points for me to believe this. For the context, i think the same as the others. That he had a hard life, and he just wanted to transmit that to the world.
I think that your comments about the painting are very interesting. I liked your words when you said that “the main one had the death behind his back”. I didn´t think it in the same way... however I believe that is valid that you have this perception because each person can find different interpretations of the same painting, as our personalities and experiences.
I think that it could be very distressing for a person to feel the experience of being chased by the death, but I think that some people, in case of an accident, might experience these feelings when they perceive are dying...
I saw in the worship. If I were there, screaming of everything that happens in my life. I would like, if I was with Edward Munch, I ask that you feel when he paint the picture; I wonder if maybe he thought he wanted to have an escape for some thinks.
I love the colors tat make extravagant, with great contrast in the painting. It is just beautiful.
Isaac, it's very interesting what you say in your comment. Its true that the guy screaming is kind of a soul. For me is more like Voldemort watching the coming Abada Kedabra spell and screaming just before he die, you know J.K. Rowling xD. Coming back to the painting, also you said that the original intention of Munch was to represent a real moment of his life, where were to friends of him. I googled a little bit and i found the picture with the two guys in it.[http://www.sjsu.edu/faculty/harris/munch.scream.jpg] P.D. i liked your last reflexion ^^
Alejandra Castellanos, I like your comment because you talk about what you think of the author´s technique, and I think it is something very interesting. I want to tell you that I felt the same when I saw this picture, I felt afraid and despaired, and as you said, when I saw this painting I didn´t want to see it again. Besides that, I think that the technique that the author used is not soft (you said that it is soft) I think this technique is kind of sharp, and it makes the picture more attractive. I really liked something that you said about the author´s reason to make this painting: “I think, maybe he had problems and with the paint he took them out of his head.” I really think that doing something you like, you can take your problems out of your mind, I do it sometimes, when I feel stressed I just paint or listen music to feel better. You made a good comment.
I WANT TO INVITE YOU TO VISIT THIS WEB PAGE WHERE YOU CAN FIND INFORMATION ABOUT EDUARD MUNCH AND HIS WORK:
This paint is called the Scream, by Edvard Munch. It´s scary because the colors are like dark and blood. My interpretation is, the guy is in a dock runnning because La Parca (the other guy in the painting) is behind him. and he doesn´t want to die yet. The color of the sky represent mistery and darkness. But after read the Munch´s description: I think that Munch was with two friends, they were walkink in a dock, but one of the friends fell down into the water and something ate him, so the water turned red. And Munch was screaming because he was shocked.
this is an amazing piece of art, and i think I have seen it before.
Isaac, I read your comment and I am totally agreed with you. Most of us said that there was a man screaming, but, is he or she really a person? I liked almost all what you said, the questions that you made, and the comparison with the Greek Mythology and how you expressed the author’s feelings. Also, I hadn’t realized that the painting was cut, so I searched for the complete one and you’re right. I just had one thing I’m not agreed with, I did like the technique, but I don’t criticize you for that. =)
I like the comment of Francisco Orozco because he talks about what he felt when he saw the paint, and the other point is that he interpretate the paint,, what did Munch feel when he painted this piece of art... the other part is that he said that a paint shows us what the actor want we to feel.
It´s single but he shows points that the other classmates don´t.
Comment to Diego: Well I in one part I agree with your comment in the one that you say that he wants to express all the problem that we are having with the contamination but If we think about that point on the year that the artist made this piece of art they didn´t have too many problems like we have it today with de dirty rivers and with the green house effects. And with the comment that I agree with you is with the one that you talk about the feelings that may be in that moment the actor was upset or he had problems with his family or in a relationship. Also in the one that it produce some sensations and that it also change someones.
Well,reading my classmates coments I analyze very good, Isaac´s aportation because I think that he has the capacity to translate what the picture is telling about.
Also, I am familiarized with Isaacs comment about the scream Why the scream?, firstly when i saw the picture i though that this was a scary one because the man face, but reading Isaac´s i saw beyond and i think that Edward wantd to express how his soul felt.
i think all the coments of me friends are good, because they all have diferent views of this painting. they all have diferent feelings and i think they have diferent forms to see the art.
speciallity i want to congratulate Isaac, because He was the most expressed in this painting because he said, that face maybe is not of a person . maybe it can be a face of a soul because hasn´t hair, i dont know exactly why, but i know that is art.
This is a very famous painting, so there are many places where you might have seen it before. (I have a t-shirt with this image). I like your comment, I like that you got involved with the painting, and now you are part of its story, because now it is your own story, and your own painting.
Depth 100 Spelling 100 Extra 0
66
I’ll begin to explain that I saw before this painting of Edvard Munch, I don´t remember where, maybe it was in some book, or some museum or some program of art, in tv, I am not sure...
My interpretation of it maybe is not like an expert people, for example an art critic or an other artist who can understand better the painting, however my personal opinion is that this image produced in me an anguish and despair sensations. I believe that the man is suffering a lot and the people are not interested in his problems, hence I think that he feels alone and perhaps is going to exploit.
Great job Gema! Good research!, I agree with you, Munch shows despair and anxiety. Please make sure you participate twice next time so you can get all the points for this exercise.
Depth 100 Spelling 100 Extra 0
66
The scream”, by Eduard Munch, is a very interesting picture. When I saw this picture the first time I felt despaired. It made me feel afraid and anxious, it was a deep feeling that I can not explain. I think that I would call this picture real art, because it made me feel different emotions. I read something about the author of this picture that made me understand the real meaning of it. Edward Munch had a really bad life when he was just a kid; his father was very strict. Besides that, Eduard Munch saw how his mother and sister died. I think that it is something very shocking for a kid. In my mind I thought about how I would feel if I see someone dying, and I did not like it. I think that Edward Munch expressed his feelings and emotions in this picture, in that difficult moment of his life.
Juan Enrique! Good job! And what you say does make sense. I have felt that anxiety as well, I think is part of our human nature. You just discovered something amazing: When you see a piece of art, sometimes you realize that the piece is portraying an idea or a feeling that we have experienced.
Franciso, that sadness you felt after looking at this painting is what is important. Make sure you apply the elements we discussed in class and also to participate more than once.
Depth 80 Spelling 80 Extra 0
53
This paint was named "The Scream" and it was done bye the famous artist Eduard Munch. Well first I wanto say that it is a good work because I can feel something no exactly but that the artist in that moment was upset about a situation that he live may be he lost a partner or he was alone in that moment. Well this are the feelings that the artist would like us to feel when we see the picture on the wall in front of our faces. First of all I feel bad because he looks like if she is screaming and I have a sensation of sadness
Great information! I am glad that you did research but I dont want you to hide your own personal perceptions behind the information you find. Next time make sure you state clearly your own opinion and interpretation.
Thanks for your comment. I see that the painting made a deep impression on you, I hope you do try to look at the picture again, the same way it helped the author, art can help us to deal with our thoughts and emotions.
You need to work harder and use the information we have covered in class to analyze the painting. Yes the artist felt something, but what type of feeling do you think he had?
Gerardo, I need you to be more accurate in your comments. I like that you start saying the feeling the piece caused on you, but then you dont describe exactly how it occured. Depth 80 Spelling 80 Extra 0
Good Diego! You brought up an interesting topic: pollution. I haven´t thought of that possiblility in the painting. Very interesting. Depth 100 Spelling 100 Extra 0
Isaac! I was quite pleased reading your comment. One observation: "But am I trying to define what did the author wanted to express or am I explaining what the painting causes on me? In other words: Is the soul screaming at me or is it screaming as a reaction of something?" In this paragraph I suggest you to rephrase the last part, when you say in other words, i think the meaning is different from what you said before. Good job! 100
Oh Isaac I almost forgot!, I will upload later today websites and a couple of pictures with the whole scene (i haven´t realized it wasn´t complete ´till you pointed it out)
Good job! I like your interpretation and you have an "eye" for the details. Just make sure next time you also write an extra comment. Depth 100 Spelling 100 Extra 0
I like your comment! Just one very important thing, next time instead of just quoting a word like in "person", make sure you explain your ideas about it, that will enrich your comment a lot.
Depth 100 Spelling 100 Extra 100 Good! This is because of your extra comment, Im glad you found the whole painting and that you are sharing it with us.
Abril, I like your comment, but you need to work in your grammar structure and the words you use, it was a bit hard to understand it. Make sure you follow the guidelines for each participation.
Gerardo J.! I like your comment! Where did you get the story? Your second comment was kind of confusing, please check your grammar structures. Good job! 90
I liked your second comment, good job. Next time please make sure you tell us why you DO like the technique (or whatever comment you made) Your grade changes to 100.
Francisco, good job! I like your analytical perspective. Next time you can do some research and give to us some more information about the particular place or river that maybe Munch was portraying. Your grade changes to 90
Enrique! Good job, but make sure next time you go a bit deeper with your explanation, besides congratulating whoever had written the original comment you need to add more of your own ideas. 95 is your grade for this activity.
Gerardo, I really like your comment because you interpret the picture almost the same like me. Reading your comment I realized that we were in the same frequency. We thouhgt that the man in black was the "Parca" as you said. Just one think, I really don`t understood the part in your comment when you said that one man felt into the river and was eaten by something, but thats ok.
Alan, I read your comment because I know your are kind of sensitive with all this stuff. The part were you said that the man is trying to get out of the picture sincerely impact me because It could be truth and I think you are right with that. Another think is that you mentioned that you felt kind of disturbed because you were like afraid. I also felt that emotions and sensations when I first saw this picture.
Thanks Alan for gave me this perception about "The scream"
Well Francisco, I agree with the posible death of Edvard Munch`s partner because it seems in the picture like he is desperate and he doesn´t know what to do. "The sream" revives us sadness and stressful sensations. I also think that a picture can remember us an uncomfortable situation like when we lose a dear and closer familiar.
i agree whit you, for me too makes me feel angusi and concern, that within me there is a feeling of relief and powerlessness. I really like your comment because you interpret the picture almost the same like me. I was trappt whit this picture beacuse i what to help that person.
The painting makes me shout like to scream, jaja, I like it this type of outlines are like make to free hand and I like it, and what I believe that it is a wharf I like, also the outlines of sky etc every.
This painting is titled "The Scream" by Edvard Munch. After our August 17th session, please start with your comments.
I’ll begin to explain that I saw before this painting of Edvard Munch, I don´t remember where, maybe it was in some book, or some museum or some program of art, in tv, I am not sure...
ReplyDeleteMy interpretation of it maybe is not like an expert people, for example an art critic or an other artist who can understand better the painting, however my personal opinion is that this image produced in me an anguish and despair sensations. I believe that the man is suffering a lot and the people are not interested in his problems, hence I think that he feels alone and perhaps is going to exploit.
Fernanda Covarrubias Noriega.
“The scream”, by Eduard Munch, is a very interesting picture. When I saw this picture the first time I felt despaired. It made me feel afraid and anxious, it was a deep feeling that I can not explain. I think that I would call this picture real art, because it made me feel different emotions.
ReplyDeleteI read something about the author of this picture that made me understand the real meaning of it. Edward Munch had a really bad life when he was just a kid; his father was very strict. Besides that, Eduard Munch saw how his mother and sister died. I think that it is something very shocking for a kid.
In my mind I thought about how I would feel if I see someone dying, and I did not like it. I think that Edward Munch expressed his feelings and emotions in this picture, in that difficult moment of his life.
Gema Paulina Fernández Castillo.
Well, firstly I don´t have words to describe what did I really feel when I saw the picture "The Scream", by Edward Munch.
ReplyDeleteBut, the thing I really admire about the picture is the way that the artist painted, because if you examine the background you can see the man that is backwards the man who is with the scram face.
I think that the artist wanted to show the way he felt, because the face and the form that he mixtures the colors, the ones that are like colors wich you can feel a deep sense inside of you and looking to the scream, remind me that sometimes I feel like that picture and its sure sometimes nobody can help you and you are like AGHHH!but this have only one sense to me, existencial angst.
Juan Enrique Ortega Solano
For me this image speaks of a person that his life was very quiet,
ReplyDeletea person who wanted to express it differently, the type of paint
used is very strange character who seems to believe that it is
expressing their feelings like the artist wanted to reflect. I
I think this character was punished for what he is doing as a gesture
despair. This image intrigues me the truth is not what to think, I
view it is very quiet, the bad is not how to express what
sorry to see this painting.
Eduardo Daniel Alcaraz Torres
This paint was named "The Scream" and it was done bye the famous artist Eduard Munch.
ReplyDeleteWell first I wanto say that it is a good work because I can feel something no exactly but that the artist in that moment was upset about a situation that he live may be he lost a partner or he was alone in that moment.
Well this are the feelings that the artist would like us to feel when we see the picture on the wall in front of our faces.
First of all I feel bad because he looks like if she is screaming and I have a sensation of sadness
Done by:
Francisco A. Orozco Cárdenas
A00343756
This famous painting was made from 1893 to 1910, some authors think that this is an expressionalist painting.
ReplyDeleteActually, they also exist some few versions of this paiting. The Munch Museum holds one of two versions and the National Gallery of Norway holds the other painted version.
The scream has been the target of several high-profile art thefts.
In my personal opinion, this painting seems to be very strange for me, but it looks like the author had some feelings to express and he express them the way he wanted.
Hernàn Orozco Rosas
A00343810
"The scream" by Edvard Munch is a really good painting. I like it but, at the time, it makes me feel scared and lost. Honestly I like the technique that the author used, it seems like something soft. Also there is a man, or something like a man, in the back of the one who is screaming, and he is just looking at him.
ReplyDeleteWhen I saw this painting before, I didn't want to see it again.
In my opinion the author wanted to say what he was feeling in that moment, the moment that he painted "The Scream". I think, maybe he had problems and with the paint he took them out of his head.
I can say this painting is real art, because it expresses feelings, but also causes feelings. The author just had an idea and he expressed it.
Alejandra Castellanos Velasco
This paiting is titled "The Scream" by Edvard Munch, is a paiting that conveys variety of things, but each one thinks what he sees in the painting, this paiting for me is a kind sentimental expressed by the type of color and shape how are jobs.
ReplyDeleteI noticed that the paiting is by a painter`s work that expresses what he thinks and is mainly in his imagination.
I liked the paiting, it`s a good piece of art.
This painting by Edvard Munch for me is weird because the paint is sad, i dont know why but just view it i start thinking about the feelings that the author wants to convey in the painting whith this face of sad or scared. But realy this painting is beauty and interesting.
ReplyDeleteI think the autor tries to tell us something of his life that he did´t likes. I like this painting by the combination of colors that he use.
Gerardo Martinez Gallegos A00343904
This painting "The scream" by edvard Munch, is a very good painting.
ReplyDeleteI really admire the picture because the man (Like a ghost) is express(feelings) the fear in his or the all the fear in the world.
I think that the background in the painting is very sad, because i think that express the fear in the world, the contamination in rivers, in mountains and the pollution in the air.
I think that this painting is art because it gives something to talk about.
Diego Fernando Mejia Gutierrez
A00343770
"The scream" by Edvard Munch.
ReplyDeleteThis picture is very shocking for me. It transmit deep emotions like fear and anxiety. It seems that the character is being trapped in a place with no way out. In my opinion the character behind the main one could be the "death" that is comming for him. The main character already knows that there is no chance to scape from his own destiny.
Alfredo Alam Herrera Carrera
A00343792
The paint is named the scream. But isn't that weird? I mean, a scream is a sound and we can't see sounds. or can we? If Bethoveen could play a "moonlight" on piano, why couldn't we look at a scream on a painting.
ReplyDeleteOh! but is he/she really screaming? Maybe you have felt the sensation that you see something horrible and you try to scream but no matter how much you open your mouth any sound come out from your throat.
And another question. Is it really a person? Look carefuly, it has strange face and no hair. Actually it looks more like a soul... for me. After anilizing the picture a little more it remeinded me of a character from the Greek Mythology. Caronte was a boatman who paddled around the Aquerón river looking for souls of people who have just died. If the soul had money to pay the trip, Caronte carried it to the inferno where Hades was. Nevertheless, if the soul didn't have money to pay, it would be punished by sataying through the river until Caronte agree to pick it up to hell.
And the painting shows exactly how do I imaging the expression of a soul who couldn't pay Caronte. But am I trying to define what did the author wanted to express or am I explaining what the painting causes on me? In other words: Is the soul screaming at me or is it screaming as a reaction of something?
Because, if we're looking for the author's feelings, here they are:
"I was walking along with two friends- the sun was setting- suddenly the sky turned blood red- I paused, feeling exhausted, and leaned on the fence. There was blood and tongues of fire above the blue-black fjord and the city- my friends walked on, and I stood there trembling with anxiety- and i sensed an infinite scream passing through nature"
He mentioned 2 friends and on the painting only apears one... well in fact that's not a mistery. Is because the picture in our blog was cut and it only shows us one Munch's friend. But why did they look so calm on the painting? Why did they keep walking on? Didn't they realize of what was happening? or it was all Munch imagination?
Reality or fiction?
However... it's art!
(even though I don't like the thecnique... haha)
Isaac Aguirre
The paint “scream” by Edward Munch is amazing, when I saw it, a lot of ideas and feelings came to me, the most important feeling that I can describe is desperation to live in a different world, but, why a different world? Well I think that because the scene is very weird, the sky is red and the ground is blue but it looks like turbid water and that cause the idea that the man or woman screams of desperation but it looks that he or she is scare too.
ReplyDeleteAnother important detail is that the person is looking to the left side like trying to look backward and I think that can represent the problems or the bad life that he had in the past.
This picture is a great example of expressionistic art because the artist is trying to show his feeling with different aspect of the painting, like color and shapes that cause different kind of feelings in a person.
Omar Hernandez Gomez
A00343791
The scream. It makes me feel weird. I don´t really know if it makes me feel kind of afraid of something, something that i can interpretated like the doomsday, according to the colors of the backgrounds.
ReplyDeleteIt is clearly a sunset, because the red themes.
It makes me think that the "person" that is screaming is actually trying to get out of the painting or screaming forthe outside. I think so for the type of movement that is doing this character, his curved body and the position of his hands are some points for me to believe this.
For the context, i think the same as the others. That he had a hard life, and he just wanted to transmit that to the world.
Alan Vincent Viera Luquín
My opinion for Alam´s comment is:
ReplyDeleteI think that your comments about the painting are very interesting. I liked your words when you said that “the main one had the death behind his back”. I didn´t think it in the same way... however I believe that is valid that you have this perception because each person can find different interpretations of the same painting, as our personalities and experiences.
I think that it could be very distressing for a person to feel the experience of being chased by the death, but I think that some people, in case of an accident, might experience these feelings when they perceive are dying...
Fernanda Covarrubias Noriega.
The Scream
ReplyDeleteI saw in the worship. If I were there, screaming of everything that happens in my life. I would like, if I was with Edward Munch, I ask that you feel when he paint the picture; I wonder if maybe he thought he wanted to have an escape for some thinks.
I love the colors tat make extravagant, with great contrast in the painting. It is just beautiful.
Isaac, it's very interesting what you say in your comment. Its true that the guy screaming is kind of a soul. For me is more like Voldemort watching the coming Abada Kedabra spell and screaming just before he die, you know J.K. Rowling xD.
ReplyDeleteComing back to the painting, also you said that the original intention of Munch was to represent a real moment of his life, where were to friends of him. I googled a little bit and i found the picture with the two guys in it.[http://www.sjsu.edu/faculty/harris/munch.scream.jpg]
P.D. i liked your last reflexion ^^
My opinion for Alejandra´s comment is:
ReplyDeleteAlejandra Castellanos, I like your comment because you talk about what you think of the author´s technique, and I think it is something very interesting.
I want to tell you that I felt the same when I saw this picture, I felt afraid and despaired, and as you said, when I saw this painting I didn´t want to see it again. Besides that, I think that the technique that the author used is not soft (you said that it is soft) I think this technique is kind of sharp, and it makes the picture more attractive.
I really liked something that you said about the author´s reason to make this painting: “I think, maybe he had problems and with the paint he took them out of his head.” I really think that doing something you like, you can take your problems out of your mind, I do it sometimes, when I feel stressed I just paint or listen music to feel better. You made a good comment.
I WANT TO INVITE YOU TO VISIT THIS WEB PAGE WHERE YOU CAN FIND
INFORMATION ABOUT EDUARD MUNCH AND HIS WORK:
http://www.ucm.es/info/echi1/imagen/pint/gritomunch.htm
Gema Paulina Fernández Castillo.
This paint is called the Scream, by Edvard Munch.
ReplyDeleteIt´s scary because the colors are like dark and blood. My interpretation is, the guy is in a dock runnning because La Parca (the other guy in the painting) is behind him. and he doesn´t want to die yet. The color of the sky represent mistery and darkness.
But after read the Munch´s description:
I think that Munch was with two friends, they were walkink in a dock, but one of the friends fell down into the water and something ate him, so the water turned red. And Munch was screaming because he was shocked.
this is an amazing piece of art, and i think I have seen it before.
By: Gerardo Jimenez 343762
All of my classmates works were excelent, was difficult to find the best comments.
ReplyDeleteBut one inspired me.
Isaac`s comment was excelent, he said that the paiting shows exactly how do I imaging the expression of a soul who couldn`t pay Caronte.
The expression for me was excelent and the form of the imagination on all of the work of Isaac was ausumn.
And another comment that was a good work was for Fernanda when she says that she doesn`t explicate than the expert people.
Isaac, I read your comment and I am totally agreed with you. Most of us said that there was a man screaming, but, is he or she really a person? I liked almost all what you said, the questions that you made, and the comparison with the Greek Mythology and how you expressed the author’s feelings. Also, I hadn’t realized that the painting was cut, so I searched for the complete one and you’re right.
ReplyDeleteI just had one thing I’m not agreed with, I did like the technique, but I don’t criticize you for that. =)
Alejandra Castellanos Velasco
I like the comment of Francisco Orozco because he talks about what he felt when he saw the paint, and the other point is that he interpretate the paint,, what did Munch feel when he painted this piece of art...
ReplyDeletethe other part is that he said that a paint shows us what the actor want we to feel.
It´s single but he shows points that the other classmates don´t.
Gerardo Jimenez Vidrio
Comment to Diego:
ReplyDeleteWell I in one part I agree with your comment in the one that you say that he wants to express all the problem that we are having with the contamination but If we think about that point on the year that the artist made this piece of art they didn´t have too many problems like we have it today with de dirty rivers and with the green house effects.
And with the comment that I agree with you is with the one that you talk about the feelings that may be in that moment the actor was upset or he had problems with his family or in a relationship.
Also in the one that it produce some sensations and that it also change someones.
Done by:
Francisco A. Orozco Cárdenas
A00343756
Well,reading my classmates coments I analyze very good, Isaac´s aportation because I think that he has the capacity to translate what the picture is telling about.
ReplyDeleteAlso, I am familiarized with Isaacs comment about the scream Why the scream?, firstly when i saw the picture i though that this was a scary one because the man face, but reading Isaac´s i saw beyond and i think that Edward wantd to express how his soul felt.
Finally, Congratulations Isaac I liked your post.
Enrique Ortega Solano
i think all the coments of me friends are good, because they all have diferent views of this painting. they all have diferent feelings and i think they have diferent forms to see the art.
ReplyDeletespeciallity i want to congratulate Isaac, because He was the most expressed in this painting because he said, that face maybe is not of a person .
maybe it can be a face of a soul because
hasn´t hair, i dont know exactly why, but i know that is art.
Gerardo Martinez Gallegos (el nuevo) jaja
Hi Fernanda,
ReplyDeleteThis is a very famous painting, so there are many places where you might have seen it before. (I have a t-shirt with this image).
I like your comment, I like that you got involved with the painting, and now you are part of its story, because now it is your own story, and your own painting.
Depth 100
Spelling 100
Extra 0
66
I’ll begin to explain that I saw before this painting of Edvard Munch, I don´t remember where, maybe it was in some book, or some museum or some program of art, in tv, I am not sure...
My interpretation of it maybe is not like an expert people, for example an art critic or an other artist who can understand better the painting, however my personal opinion is that this image produced in me an anguish and despair sensations. I believe that the man is suffering a lot and the people are not interested in his problems, hence I think that he feels alone and perhaps is going to exploit.
Great job Gema! Good research!, I agree with you, Munch shows despair and anxiety.
ReplyDeletePlease make sure you participate twice next time so you can get all the points for this exercise.
Depth 100
Spelling 100
Extra 0
66
The scream”, by Eduard Munch, is a very interesting picture. When I saw this picture the first time I felt despaired. It made me feel afraid and anxious, it was a deep feeling that I can not explain. I think that I would call this picture real art, because it made me feel different emotions.
I read something about the author of this picture that made me understand the real meaning of it. Edward Munch had a really bad life when he was just a kid; his father was very strict. Besides that, Eduard Munch saw how his mother and sister died. I think that it is something very shocking for a kid.
In my mind I thought about how I would feel if I see someone dying, and I did not like it. I think that Edward Munch expressed his feelings and emotions in this picture, in that difficult moment of his life.
Juan Enrique! Good job! And what you say does make sense. I have felt that anxiety as well, I think is part of our human nature. You just discovered something amazing: When you see a piece of art, sometimes you realize that the piece is portraying an idea or a feeling that we have experienced.
ReplyDeleteDepth 100
Spelling 100
Extra 0
66
Eduardo Daniel:
ReplyDeleteWhat is the action that the character committed in order to get punished?
I like that you started telling a story, that shows that you really observed the painting.
Depth 80 (lenght)
Spelling 80
Extra 0
53
Franciso, that sadness you felt after looking at this painting is what is important.
ReplyDeleteMake sure you apply the elements we discussed in class and also to participate more than once.
Depth 80
Spelling 80
Extra 0
53
This paint was named "The Scream" and it was done bye the famous artist Eduard Munch.
Well first I wanto say that it is a good work because I can feel something no exactly but that the artist in that moment was upset about a situation that he live may be he lost a partner or he was alone in that moment.
Well this are the feelings that the artist would like us to feel when we see the picture on the wall in front of our faces.
First of all I feel bad because he looks like if she is screaming and I have a sensation of sadness
Hernán,
ReplyDeleteGreat information! I am glad that you did research but I dont want you to hide your own personal perceptions behind the information you find. Next time make sure you state clearly your own opinion and interpretation.
Depth 100
Spelling 100
Extra 0
66
Alejandra Castellanos,
ReplyDeleteThanks for your comment. I see that the painting made a deep impression on you, I hope you do try to look at the picture again, the same way it helped the author, art can help us to deal with our thoughts and emotions.
Depth 100
Spelling 100
Extra 0
66
Juan Diego,
ReplyDeleteYou need to work harder and use the information we have covered in class to analyze the painting. Yes the artist felt something, but what type of feeling do you think he had?
Depth 80
Spelling 0
Extra 0
27
Gerardo, I need you to be more accurate in your comments. I like that you start saying the feeling the piece caused on you, but then you dont describe exactly how it occured.
ReplyDeleteDepth 80
Spelling 80
Extra 0
53
Good Diego! You brought up an interesting topic: pollution. I haven´t thought of that possiblility in the painting. Very interesting.
ReplyDeleteDepth 100
Spelling 100
Extra 0
66
Alam,
ReplyDeleteI liked your comment, particularly how you gave specific roles to each one of the characters.
Make sure you write the asked lenght next time.
Depth 80
Spelling 100
Extra 0
60
Isaac! I was quite pleased reading your comment. One observation: "But am I trying to define what did the author wanted to express or am I explaining what the painting causes on me? In other words: Is the soul screaming at me or is it screaming as a reaction of something?" In this paragraph I suggest you to rephrase the last part, when you say in other words, i think the meaning is different from what you said before.
ReplyDeleteGood job!
100
Oh Isaac I almost forgot!, I will upload later today websites and a couple of pictures with the whole scene (i haven´t realized it wasn´t complete ´till you pointed it out)
ReplyDeleteOmar,
ReplyDeleteGood job! I like your interpretation and you have an "eye" for the details. Just make sure next time you also write an extra comment.
Depth 100
Spelling 100
Extra 0
66
Vincent!
ReplyDeleteI like your comment! Just one very important thing, next time instead of just quoting a word like in "person", make sure you explain your ideas about it, that will enrich your comment a lot.
Depth 100
Spelling 100
Extra 100 Good! This is because of your extra comment, Im glad you found the whole painting and that you are sharing it with us.
100
Good Fernanda! I like your other comment, that changes your grade to 100
ReplyDeleteAbril, I like your comment, but you need to work in your grammar structure and the words you use, it was a bit hard to understand it. Make sure you follow the guidelines for each participation.
ReplyDeleteDepth 80
Spelling 80
Extra 0
53
Gema, great participation in your second comm. Your grade now is 100.
ReplyDeleteGerardo J.! I like your comment! Where did you get the story? Your second comment was kind of confusing, please check your grammar structures.
ReplyDeleteGood job!
90
Juan Diego A,
ReplyDeleteYou made a better job in your second comment, keep improving.
Your grade for this activity is 80
Alejandra C.
ReplyDeleteI liked your second comment, good job. Next time please make sure you tell us why you DO like the technique (or whatever comment you made)
Your grade changes to 100.
Francisco, good job! I like your analytical perspective. Next time you can do some research and give to us some more information about the particular place or river that maybe Munch was portraying. Your grade changes to 90
ReplyDeleteEnrique! Good job, but make sure next time you go a bit deeper with your explanation, besides congratulating whoever had written the original comment you need to add more of your own ideas. 95 is your grade for this activity.
ReplyDeleteGerardo M,
ReplyDeleteYour grade is now 80. Your second comment should be yours, it can be based on one classmate´s comment but you need to add your own thoughts.
About Gerardo`s comment:
ReplyDeleteGerardo, I really like your comment because you interpret the picture almost the same like me. Reading your comment I realized that we were in the same frequency. We thouhgt that the man in black was the "Parca" as you said.
Just one think, I really don`t understood the part in your comment when you said that one man felt into the river and was eaten by something, but thats ok.
Thank you for that really interesting comment
Alfredo Alam Herrera Carrera
A00343792
About Alan´s comment:
ReplyDeleteAlan, I read your comment because I know your are kind of sensitive with all this stuff.
The part were you said that the man is trying to get out of the picture sincerely impact me because It could be truth and I think you are right with that.
Another think is that you mentioned that you felt kind of disturbed because you were like afraid. I also felt that emotions and sensations when I first saw this picture.
Thanks Alan for gave me this perception about "The scream"
Alfredo Alam Herrera Carrera
A00343792
About Francisco´s comment:
ReplyDeleteWell Francisco, I agree with the posible death of Edvard Munch`s partner because it seems in the picture like he is desperate and he doesn´t know what to do. "The sream" revives us sadness and stressful sensations. I also think that a picture can remember us an uncomfortable situation like when we lose a dear and closer familiar.
Really good comment Paco...Thanks for all
Alfredo Alam Herrera Carrera
A00343792
About Fernanda`s comment:
ReplyDeletei agree whit you, for me too makes me feel angusi and concern, that within me there is a feeling of relief and powerlessness.
I really like your comment because you interpret the picture almost the same like me. I was trappt whit this picture beacuse i what to help that person.
by: Nelva MIldred Hernandez Sosa. A00343778
The painting makes me shout like to scream, jaja, I like it this type of outlines are like make to free hand and I like it, and what I believe that it is a wharf I like, also the outlines of sky etc every.
ReplyDelete